Home > Blogs > Get on the Bus > Archives > 2008 > May > 28 > Entry
Luckie: This is how charters should work

Clayton Luckie
State Rep. Clayton Luckie, D-Dayton and a former city school board member, sent out a letter today praising a new partnership between Dayton Public Schools and East End Community Community School.
Luckie is a huge charter school critic, but he says charters can work under this model. Here’s his letter:
May 27, 2008
Dear Editor,
I am writing in response to the article by Scott Elliott (“Dayton Public Schools to absorb East End charter school,” May 21, 2008) announcing the absorption of East End Community School by the Dayton Public School District. This is a prime example of how charter schools and public schools can operate harmoniously.
This merger is truly a win-win situation: East End will move into a brand new building - built by Dayton Public Schools - and will continue to operate independently. The Dayton Public Schools Board, though, will monitor the school closely as the quality control for what happens in the classroom, and the enrollment will count for DPS for school funding purposes. Overall, the merger itself will result in a symbiotic relationship for both entities and positive outcomes for the students and the community.
I congratulate the Dayton Public School District on this breakthrough in education for Ohio. This partnership will no doubt lead the way for many other similar relationships between charter schools and public school districts, ultimately improving the quality of education across our great state.
Sincerely,
Clayton R. Luckie (D-Dayton)
State Representative
39th House District
Permalink | Comments (6) | Post your comment | Categories: Dayton Public Schools

E-mail
E-mail
E-mail
Comments
By charterschoolhater
May 29, 2008 4:37 PM | Link to this
Although I am a bit off topic here. I must take this opportunity to inform Davidss2 and others on the blog of some really good things that will come from having State Sen. Austria in congress. I am a democrat. Mr. Austria is an republican. However, I am going to work in his campaign despite not even living in his district. The why is very important here. A very real threat to funding for programs for mentally challenged adults was brewing during the latter days of the Taft administration. This was led by Taft and his republican allies in the Ohio House and the Ohio Senate. Senator Austria bucked the leadership of his party and opposed these cuts. The proposed cuts would have been devastating to the lifestyles of the many Ohioans who are both mentally and physically challenged adults. What really angers me is that when cuts are to be made, they always pick on people least able to fight for themselves. This story has a happy ending, though. Senator Austria spoke up for those least able to fight. His efforts delayed action on the bill. We then had a change in the governor’s chair and the challenge to these people then died. We need people like Austria fighting for us in Washington. Although this has nothing to do with this blog, I just wanted people to know what type of person Steve Austria is. I am proud to call him friend, even though we have about a 90% differ politically most of the time.
By Davidss2`
May 29, 2008 7:52 AM | Link to this
Charterschoolhater; the folks will keep electing Lucky just like they elected McLin over a very capable opponent because she is the same race. Sometimes people get the politicians and schools they deserve. The people also need to watch the musical chairs as Husted, Austria, and others being term-limited out of office, look for other jobs at the public trough. I was just told by Austria’s office yesterday that he’s running for congress. They cut $22 million from state income by exempting military retirements and are stealing tobacco money and scrimping to save hundreds of millions of shortfall in state income now. Duh. Somehow his office couldn’t see that if they exempt military retirement, they should exempt all retiree’s incomes from state tax!!! They figure the military folks will be more definite to vote for them?
By chartecshoolhter
May 28, 2008 10:28 PM | Link to this
What is amazing here to me is that Clayton Luckie is telling us how charter schools should work? This coming from a person who during his term as DPS School board member could not figure out how public schools should work? I really fell sorry for those he represents in the house. Perhaps they will wise up when he comes up for re-election and throw him out on his butt.
By Oldprof
May 28, 2008 9:34 PM | Link to this
I’m not certain how this is a model for future endeavors. I am certain that the charter school experiment has failed, it has not delivered anything NEAR what was promised, and continuing to use children as guinea pigs in this experiment is flagrantly irresponsible. The East End collaboration is nice, but overall the charter school hypothesis is a wrong-headed attempt to fix public education through inappropriate free-market theories, rather than doing the hard work necessary to effect genuine improvement.
By btlsmum
May 28, 2008 3:48 PM | Link to this
Actually Jim, it’s an even bigger win for DPS than simply gaining a new school. They let East End do “mostly” (therein lies the rub for East End) their own thing for 5 years. In the end, DPS either gets to accept credit for the success of the new school model or the chance to say, “It’s not our fault. We tried” if it doesn’t perform.
By Jim
May 28, 2008 10:25 AM | Link to this
So, the way that charters are supposed to work is that they should be “absorbed” by a traditional public district, the district should have complete oversight of the school and receive all the funding for the school’s students? That school won’t be any different than the other failing DPS schools. Nice try.