DaytonDailyNews.com

By Bahh Hummbug

November 27, 2006 09:09 PM | Link to this

All of Dayton might as well close

By hobo bob

November 27, 2006 07:13 PM | Link to this

Some of these posters sound on the edge of hysteria, really “Joap” calm down:)

There is no good being performed, to the public or to the business owners by continuing this blog. The message that is being imprinted on the community has ranged from supportive to critical. Being in business often means being in business by yourself, it is hard enough without all of this.

It is time that the DDN pull the plug on this blog and move on. It’s time for everybody to move on. Eat where you want.

By Melissa

November 27, 2006 04:43 PM | Link to this

We had brunch at Blue Moon in Centerville yesterday. I hope they can do a better job in the future. We won’t be going back for brunch anytime soon. They weren’t packed and it took forever for the waitress and the food. Some items were even forgotten. Maybe it was just changes happening with the other place closing. Dinners have always been great. We don’t want to see Centerville lose another great restaurant. We always recommend it. Lunches are a great idea. Support our local businesses.

By Melissa

November 27, 2006 04:37 PM | Link to this

Blue Moon was our favorite restaurant. It was always our first choice whenever we went out. We were sorry to see it close. Our oldest was looking forward to dinners there with dates. She is sad that she will never be able to experience our #1 place. We have eaten at Eclipse (Blue Moon) several times. It is great to start having decent places in Centerville finally. There are way too many fast food and chinese places. Nothing against chinese food as we like that as well.

By DOC HOLIDAY

November 27, 2006 02:34 PM | Link to this

WELL IT’S CLOSED. IF I LIVED IN THE OREGON DISTRICT I WOULD FEEL CHEATED. THE CITY OF DAYTON WILL PROMISE YOU THE “BLUE MOON” AND DELIVER NEXT TO NOTHING. LOOK AT ALL THE HELP THEY GAVE THE SCHUSTER CENTER…..AND THEN LISTEN TO THE FOLKS THAT PROVIDED THE CASH…..NOT REALLY VERY HAPPY WITH DAYTON. LOOK AT THE STREETS IN OREGON…THE CITY HAS STAYED ON TOP OF THAT. IT’S OK IF YOU’RE A DENTIST…MONEY IN THE BANK. DAYTON IS CLOSING, MAYOR McKLIN WERE IN TROUBLE, QUIT WORRING ABOUT HATS.

By Matt

November 27, 2006 01:22 PM | Link to this

My first date with my now wife was at Blue Moon, good food, kinda expensive, and the place wasn’t as quiet as I thought that night. Our waitress was friendly and we got great service. That was the only time we went, I was wanting to return on our aniversary so I guess I’ll have to make other plans. I am all for supporting local buisiness in Dayton, that is why it’s sad that Gem City Records was bought out by a corp. The Best place to eat in Dayton by far is still Amar or Ajanta.

By bengalfan

November 27, 2006 10:28 AM | Link to this

Wife and I both like the Blue Moon. Been to Eclipse twice, and BOTH times the HOST or reserv. planner or whoever he is was EXTREMELY RUDE. Just 2 weeks ago we went there with 4 other friends and the restaurant was nearly EMPTY at 6:30pm on a Sat.night. We were then surprised when we were told he could not seat us until after 9:30. Mind you, this is 6 PAYING customers turned away! He THEN thought it would be funny to ask if we would like him to order a PIZZA for us!Gee,wonder why one is closing?

By Beth

November 27, 2006 10:21 AM | Link to this

I have only eaten at Blue Moon once in the Oregon District. It was a much different approach to dining then other restaurants. At Blue Moon, there is no rush to get you out of there as soon as possible. The food was delicious, but I’m a college student, and don’t have money to be buying much more than Taco Bell right now! But I also think with the new developement downtown, it would be smart of Blue Moon to try and hang on to the business.. good luck to them in any decision.

By Dee

November 27, 2006 09:45 AM | Link to this

While it is sad that Dayton is losing a business, I think what alot of you are overlooking is that the owners are closing their Dayton location and leaving their Centerville location open!!! It’s obvious that they want to cater to those south of town. I say adios if that is how they want to be, since this style of restaurant was started in Dayton!!!! It was the owners decision to leave Dayton for Centerville, why is everyone overlooking that???

By susan

November 27, 2006 08:46 AM | Link to this

my experience at the Blue Moon was a very good one; excellent service, great atmosphere, delicious and beautifully prepared food.sorry to see them go.

By joap

November 26, 2006 08:30 PM | Link to this

The fact of the matter is that people always seem happy to go to J. Alexander’s because they know they are going to get the highest quality product, fanatical attention to service with a fine dining feel in a casual environment. You cannot say that chain restuarants are shutting down local restuarants: they are doing that themselves by giving poor service, poor food and high prices. J. Alexander’s is a great place and I will continue to support it because it is a community friendly restuarant!

By joap

November 26, 2006 08:23 PM | Link to this

in addition we own houses here, work here, shop here, send our kids to schools here and employee roughly 150 employees that live here, shop here, pay city taxes. yes chain restaurants are big but the fact that they are big is what makes them so great for OUR community because they have a big company backing them so they can pay high dollar salaries, donate big dollars to local charities and schools.

By joap

November 26, 2006 08:16 PM | Link to this

To “The Smart Woman” who made a comment earlier: I recently worked for the “chain” restaurant J. Alexander’s and I know first hand that they order their produce in fresh 6 times a week from a local vendor. We get in fresh seafood 6 times a week from a local vendor. I also know that they donate thousands and thousands of dollars each year to local charites such as hannahs teasure chest, all the local school fund raisers. How can you say this is not contributing to our community??

By hobo bob

November 26, 2006 06:07 PM | Link to this

Reading all these post are making me hungry. Cheesecake anyone?

By M.D.

November 26, 2006 04:45 PM | Link to this

I’ve only eaten at the Blue Moon once and it was a very nice experience. Yes the food was pricey, but well worth it. I was looking forward to going back but it looks like I’ve missed my chance. I’ll have to check out Eclipse!

By Shay

November 26, 2006 04:00 PM | Link to this

Dayton residents must support Dayton businesses or else the quality of life and tax base in the city suffers. At the same time, restaurant owners must offer reasonably priced entrees. Restaurant owners must realize that Dayton area residents do not want to pay New York City prices for food. In an area the size of Dayton, restaurants must rely on repeat visitors. There are only so many times in a month that a typical Dayton household will spend $100 on a meal for two.

By Chris

November 26, 2006 11:20 AM | Link to this

Dayton has two gems in the Pine Club and El Meson … I live in in LA and these are two places I hope never go away!

By Robert Guttman

November 26, 2006 11:08 AM | Link to this

First, the restaurant was inconsistent at best - that includes services and food quality - and generally mediocre execution. It’s saving grace at that location (for a while) was that it had better food than Cafe Blvd and the Jazz Room but it still lagged, significantly, places like Meadowlark and The Winds. Second, the community tends to support restaurants that are more mainstream (chains) and let’s face it, Dayton dining is mired in the 1970’s. Coco’s and The Green didn’t help either.

By steve

November 26, 2006 01:00 AM | Link to this

long live the pine club

By Bryan

November 26, 2006 12:22 AM | Link to this

Restaurants do close. Happens all the time, so this is not so surprising. On the other hand, have you noticed a trend — when a downtown business opens a south location (especially in Centerville), the downtown location closes within a couple of years. Let’s hope that doesn’t happen when Square One opens its Centerville location.

Look for a new restaurant or club to open in the Blue Moon space before too long however.

By steve

November 25, 2006 10:04 PM | Link to this

its very sad when a independently owned business closes.im afraid the blue moon is just the beginning of local establishments closing down.you can blame it on chain restaurants but its more complex than that.dayton(and i mean all you suburbs too)was built by the manufacturing industry.look around now and you will see that dayton is trying to find a new identity.it doesnt help that the blue moon leaves and goes to centerville.i believe a place like our beloved city can rebound but…….

By Robin

November 25, 2006 07:48 AM | Link to this

The Oregon district is not just an exciting place to go. It’s filled with the heart & soul, sweat, tears and joy of people & families trying to live their dream. We all love to live, work and play here and losing Greg and Beth and the Blue Moon staff is a sadness we feel on many levels. I hope people remember to try and support all small businesses trying to make a difference in our community.

By Logan

November 21, 2006 10:28 PM | Link to this

The Blue Moon closed its Oregon District Restaurant today.

By TD

November 21, 2006 04:20 PM | Link to this

I really love the Oregon District location. Great food, great bartenders. Although the atmosphere is both pleasing and unique, I think the interior could use an update/some improvement. Talent in this area is very nearby.

By Cody

November 20, 2006 07:09 PM | Link to this

Also, BM has relatively recently released a new menu compiling the best entrees of each year they have been open. The prices on this new menu are very reasonably priced for the great quality of food served. To those of you that dine with us regularly, thank you for your support. For those of you who have never been, we’d love to see you give us a chance to impress you. The Blue Moon is becoming one of few of its kind in Dayton; please help to keep us around for years and years to come.

By Cody

November 20, 2006 07:09 PM | Link to this

I have been an employee at the Blue Moon (Oregon District Location) for almost two years, and was absolutely heartbroken to see this article. Although it may sound quite cheesy, the Fitzgerald’s are like a family to the employees. They are always there to talk with you, whether it is business related or personal. We have all seen their children grow, and the kindness that the Fitzgerald’s display on a daily basis.

By Bob/chef/owner Bahn Mai Thai Cafe

November 19, 2006 09:59 PM | Link to this

It was sad to read the story about the Blue Moon and the Eclipse in this sad situation. Many other small local restuarants are probably in the same boat. Concerning the Green and Dayton Mall, What the developers where trying to do is imitate a big city setting of a neighborhood with its eclectic shops and restaurants. Thats what makes a city like Chicago, New York, D.C. unique. What we got were chain restaurants and shops, but this is what people here want. Support your local restaurants.

By Marilyn

November 19, 2006 04:59 PM | Link to this

My husband and I frequent Eclipse. There have only been 2-3 occasions since Eclipse opened that the food was sub-par. We were just there this past Friday and throughly enjoyed the food. The staff are pleasant and the atmosphere is wonderful. This restaurant will sorely be missed. We wish them the best and hope they find their way to keep at least one of their restaurants open.

By Beverly

November 19, 2006 11:08 AM | Link to this

On 10/17 I emailed Blue Moon for more info on reserving a date for a private party for 25+ people. I didn’t receive a reply.

Quality of food is most important, but service is really big to me. I was disappointed not to receive a reply to my private party inquiry, but the same thing happened to me from CoCo’s. Never heard back from them either. I did hear back from Pacchia Prima right away. I do wish Blue Moon all the best, though, and would be sad to see them close.

By hobo bob

November 18, 2006 08:27 PM | Link to this

Whenever a business expands it exposes itself to risk. Of course the hope is for success. My wife and I had dinner at the Centerville location, it was very nice. If the original location worked perhaps a focus on that single location, with a rebirth of energy will do the trick. It’s also a cautionary tale to business owners to keep assets, finances and corporations separate from each other. To be fair, the Centerville location has history of other restaurants that have failed there.

By Beth

November 18, 2006 01:15 PM | Link to this

We would also not spend the money to advertise, promote and print coupons and then shoot ourselves in the foot by treating the user badly!

By Beth

November 18, 2006 01:12 PM | Link to this

as much as I would to get a similar item at Blue Moon. We certainly as owners never snub anyone who comes in for a light meal! I continually encourage people to feel free to have an appetizer and/or a salad, not everyone wants to eat a huge amount. If you have ever been treated badly because of this you should have let us know. We don’t want any server treating someone badly for anything

By Beth

November 18, 2006 01:06 PM | Link to this

I don’t think that most of us believe that you should “never” eat at a chain, (we occasionally go to Bravos, when we get a chance to go somewhere other than our restaurants)The point is that when there is a three hour wait at the new chains as opposed to a 30 min or no wait at Blue Moon, someone should scratch their head and say hey, maybe we should go to somewhere else. We are certainly aware that many people believe that we are extravagantly priced, but if I order a spinach pasta and a salad

By "Dr. Caroline"

November 18, 2006 01:04 PM | Link to this

Independent restaurants like Blue Moon and Eclipse reflect the uniqueness of the owners’ vision and personality which is something chain restaurants can not offer. Creative people such as chefs and restaurant owners provide an aesthetic experience for diners that reflect aspects of themselves … and what a wonderful experience Greg and Beth have created for so many. Best Wishes.

By John

November 18, 2006 09:46 AM | Link to this

We ate at the eclipse for my birthday and we loved it. Its probably the fact that Dayton identifies dining as eating at a Longhorn that dooms places like the Blue Moon.

By T.K.

November 18, 2006 02:40 AM | Link to this

The Fitzgeralds are REAL people, with real kids, and real employees they also have two REALLY GOOD restaurants that offer fantastic food and an ambiance that is unmatched by any other restaurant in the area in my opinion. I am an employee at the Oregon districts Bluemoon and love the pride that is taken by all the staff on every plate that leaves that kitchen. I love the guests that come in and relax enjoy good wine good food in a wonderful warm atmosphere and as a team we hope to see you again

By Kevin P

November 18, 2006 02:10 AM | Link to this

I’m very sorry to hear the news especially after my wife and I and another couple all had fantastic meals in the Centerville location last weekend. As a local business owner and fellow entrepeneur in local food service for the past 20 years I feel “locals” owe it to the community to support local businesses to help preserve our unique identity.

By David Esrati

November 18, 2006 12:01 AM | Link to this

I’m happy to report- that when I stopped by tonight at 6:30- to wish them the best- the Blue Moon was filling up. The article said- if they didn’t find a buyer- they would close, but, it didn’t say they were going to close right now. Maybe, if everyone gives them a chance to prove themselves- they may be able to stay. Lisa Grigsby is right- 3000 new restaurant seats hurt all the existing restaurants- because Dayton isn’t in growth mode to support it. Go watch osu beat mi at the downtown BM sat.

By David Esrati

November 17, 2006 11:56 PM | Link to this

I’m amazed that people comment- who’ve never been to the Blue Moon or Eclipse. I’m even more amazed, that Daytonian’s, who are generally friendly and kind, have a need to take pot shots at this couples baby- while it is in critical care. Don’t tell me you haven’t had crappy service at a chain. Everyone has a bad day- but feeling the need to share your negativity here? The Fitzgeralds are real people, with kids, employees, and their entire nest egg wrapped in these two restaurants.

By Kim

November 17, 2006 11:21 PM | Link to this

I’d have to say I have a mixed opinion of this story. My husband and I have a policy of not eating at chain restaurants when we go out for date nights. However, I ate at Blue Moon once with my best friend last year and it was a terrible experience. We had a coupon (from the internet), and apparently even though they issued them, they had no intention of honoring them. Once we presented it, we were treated horribly. I never went back after that experience.

By hobo bob

November 17, 2006 09:41 PM | Link to this

Most of the negative comments are from people who couldn’t run a hot dog stand on a good day. They couldn’t handle it. Food service, any food service is a tough business.

By Greg Fitzgerald

November 17, 2006 09:25 PM | Link to this

Just wanted to say Thank You, my family ( Beth, Easton, Rose and Kaden )for making my life a dream come true. You are a inspiration to anyone who knows you. The last 2 days have been stressful, but hey thats the business I choose.I thank all of you for your comments it has givin me a great insight of the business.To Daniel Warner my G.M. who is sticking with me, Tom Fecke my F.O.B. who worked this weekend with no pay, my staff and friends , Thank You. Greg fitzgerald, Owner/executive chef

By Jim

November 17, 2006 08:06 PM | Link to this

Denny - Did Applebee’s or The Cheesecake factory buy from you? Last I checked, Pacchia and Cafe Blvd are independents. I can’t tell you who Blue Moon buys from, but I know it’s not the same source as Cheesecake Factory.

By Jim

November 17, 2006 08:05 PM | Link to this

Denny - Did Applebee’s or The Cheesecake factory buy from you? Last I checked, Pacchia and Cafe Blvd are independents. I can’t tell you who Blue Moon buys from, but I know it’s not the same source as Cheesecake Factory.

By Denny

November 17, 2006 07:14 PM | Link to this

I used to live in Bellbrook and grow veggies, herbs and edible flowers. The Blue Moon never bought from me. Pacchia and Cafe Blvd did buy from me. Isn’t that interesting?

By Jim

November 17, 2006 05:58 PM | Link to this

The chain and the independent both support local business and employee local workers. However, the independent tends to form a relationship and buy from a local farmer. The chain tends to purchase in volume and process at a factory, hence the price advantage. I don’t know if it is my palette or my conscience that prefers the taste of an heirloom tomato from Bellbrook over a greenhouse tomato from California. Support your independent restaurant and farmer!

By Ray

November 17, 2006 05:57 PM | Link to this

Anyone who considers a chain restaurant matches up to a restaurant of this caliber, should keep going to Applebees. A restaurant is one of the most difficult to keep open, and it is a shame when a good one is feeling the pinch. I am glad they went public. We’ll be going soon.

By PJ

November 17, 2006 04:49 PM | Link to this

To dumb woman, oh sorry I mean the english scholar. Big chains do support local economy, and as I said I am 100% behind local business. My point is half of these post are saying people ruin local business by going elsewhere. If all the big chains went out in your area, it would create more bad than good. I was a restuarant owner that went out of business, because a lot of the big business moved to another area. Business supports business. All you liberals need to get you head out and think

By Bill

November 17, 2006 04:41 PM | Link to this

For the people complaining about the price of a drink at the Blue Moon, I was charged $22.50 for a shot of scotch at the Cheesecake Factory. Not only that- but, ads in the menu? There is something wrong with the dining experience when I feel like I’m getting milked for every last cent. What kind of “service” is that? Totally opposite of my experiences at the Blue Moon, where it feels like a special evening centered on my enjoyment of the food and atmosphere.

By smart woman

November 17, 2006 04:34 PM | Link to this

PJ is wrong (and has several gramatical errors). Liberals do not “ruin the economy.” Comparing Applebees to Blue Moon Bistro is a travesty. Yes, chains have local managers. But do they serve fresh produce? Do they help support OUR economy? The purpose of this article is to bring the community together to help support a locally owned business. Oh, hold on, I am going to go get some fried onion and ranch dressing so I can contribute to our nation’s obesity problem.

By Frank

November 17, 2006 04:34 PM | Link to this

The Blue Moon is for Limp wristed, yellow belly, tree hug’in liberals, who say that big business is driving out the “little” guy. It’s only a matter of time until we hear something along the lines of we need to support local “Culture” and help drive additional business into the local areas and to do so we need to raise taxes to improve infrastructure and appeal.

By Zack

November 17, 2006 04:22 PM | Link to this

Applebees = Vomit

By PJ

November 17, 2006 04:15 PM | Link to this

Apparently Jackie A, you have never researched any statistics. I agree that supporting local business is first and for most what needs to be done. Big chains though, attract other business, and more people to help your community grow. All I am saying is swearing off chains isn’t the way to go.

By Jackie A.

November 17, 2006 03:28 PM | Link to this

Did I read that comment by PJ correctly? “Liberals ruin the economy”? Please! The truth is that neither chain restaurants, nor liberals (nor any particular politically-affiliated consumer demographic) ruin the economy - - IGNORANCE RUINS THE ECONOMY. The belief in things like voodoo economics and trickle-down spending in a political climate wrought with fear: that kind of idiocy ruins the economy. There is evidence that contributing to a community’s local culture positively impacts its economy.

By J.L. Hein

November 17, 2006 02:40 PM | Link to this

Truffles, Blue Moon, Eclipse, Madison’s Bistro, Citilites….

All great INDPENDENT restaurants. C’mon folks, support local restaurants, especially good ones such as these! Why wait ridiculously long times to be served pasta out of a bag? I would rather go once a month to one of these then to a mediocre chain once a week.

And, what is up with the aversion to downtown? Great theatre, movies, market, arts…get out of the burbs and live!

By PJ

November 17, 2006 02:36 PM | Link to this

As a former restaurant owner I can feel for the current owners. When all you people start talking about only supporting local restaurants though, I think you aren’t paying attention to the facts. These so called big chains are run by local managers, with local kids on the baseball team. Some big chains are ownded by one guy(mike scanlon-applebees), and what he does locally is amazing. Liberals ruin the economy not big chains. Get your facts straight.

By TJ

November 17, 2006 02:34 PM | Link to this

It’s a rip off anyways.

By Foodie

November 17, 2006 02:17 PM | Link to this

I agree that eating locally (ie non-chain restaurants) is preferable. However, I found Blue Moon to be overpriced. Cafe Boulevard and Thai 9 have both managed to thrive in the same area. Why? Not overpriced. I found the wine list at Blue Moon to be especially outrageous.

By lisa grigsby

November 17, 2006 02:12 PM | Link to this

Sadly I think whay Beth & Greg are feeling is the addition of over 3000 resataurant seats in the Miami Valley in the last 6 months.

When any new business opens, it’s existing competition always feel a slow down.

I applaud Beth & Greg for going public and letting their customers know that now more than ever, they need their patronage.

I wish them all the best, and I’ll be dining there again, soon!

By John

November 17, 2006 01:42 PM | Link to this

The Dayton Daily News is shady. They’re getting out of Dayton lock stock and barrel and refuse to publicize any community events located in Dayton such as holiday home tours. So why would they want to put any positive spin on business in downtown Dayton? The DDN Publisher is rumored to dislike Dayton.

By Gene

November 17, 2006 12:15 PM | Link to this

Carl has a good point about eating a local restaurants as opposed to eating at chains. But that really applies to every business…. do you shop at Home Depot rather than go to a more locally owned hardware store. You may pay a little more but you help the local community and generally get better service. My point is that most people simply don’t want to pay more than $10 or $15 a meal - no matter what the value is of a more expensive meal. The chains give you a lot of food for little money.

By Don

November 17, 2006 12:15 PM | Link to this

Our last experience at Blue Moon was fantastic, as have been most of our visits. We take job candidates there as a way of showing some of the best restaurants that Dayton has to offer.

By fenwah

November 17, 2006 11:30 AM | Link to this

Whoa!! Where did the 9/11 reference go as the reason for the demise of Blue Moon? Come on DDN editors…what’s going on here? Very shady reporting by the DDN to remove a paragraph from this news article stating that the owners of Blue Moon were contributing their restaurant’s demise to 9/11 instead of their own incompetance to run a business.

Shame on you DDN. You are losing credibility as a newspaper.

By Carl

November 17, 2006 11:25 AM | Link to this

I had the good fortune of eating at both Blue Moon and Eclipse during my time in Dayton. The food was great, the atmosphere was great, I never had a bad experience. I have to agree with David Esrati…if you choose to dine at places like Cheesecake Factory or PF Changs over places like Pizza Factory or Thai 9, you’re actively working against your community. Its nothing less than capital flight, you are sending the bulk of your dollars out of Ohio. Think global, eat local.

By Betty

November 17, 2006 11:19 AM | Link to this

I’ve ate a couple times at the Blue Moon, it’s OK. But the Eclipse I’ve never ate at. I pass it daily, and actually thought it was a Salon. If the outside had appearance, it might draw people in more.

By Shannon & Travis Dixon

November 17, 2006 11:16 AM | Link to this

We are truly saddened to hear about the possibility of Blue Moon closing. We celebrate special occassions there including our wedding anniversary. The food, the atmosphere, the people more than justify the prices. Good luck to Beth & Greg.

By Connie

November 17, 2006 09:57 AM | Link to this

During the four years that our daughter attended UD we always looked forward to a meal at Blue Moon. While we won’t be in Dayton to enjoy it any more, Blue Moon is a great restaurant with good food, a nice atmosphere and a friendly staff. Best of Luck

By D Turner

November 17, 2006 09:56 AM | Link to this

I think the reason national chain restaurants are so popular is that you know what you are getting when you walk in the door, no matter what city you happen to be in. People expect a decent value for their money and a pleasant experience for their time. I think it’s human nature to return to known sources of both of these things before venturing out to try something unproven. It sounds like Blue Moon and Eclipse have a small following of loyal patrons, but I have never been there myself.

By Steve Swope

November 17, 2006 09:54 AM | Link to this

Beth, if you think some business advice may help you to keep the restaurants running, let me suggest that you call the local schools of business.

MBA students at UD, WSU, Miami, and Ohio State University (where I’m enrolled) are often available for consultation in conjunction with class projects. All it will cost you is your time.

I’ve not been to Blue Moon, but Eclipse has been outstanding. The name change was a good idea (capitalize upon the existing brand image of Blue Moon).

By John

November 17, 2006 09:37 AM | Link to this

Personally, I won’t be sad to see Eclipse go. I ate their twice and the experience was below average both times and certainly below average for the price that we paid for our dinner. It’s a shame that it took the owners so long to realize that Eclipse was a losing proposition.

The Blue Moon, on the other hand, impressed me on a couple of occasions. But, as others note, you have to understand what your customers want.

By Charles R

November 17, 2006 09:34 AM | Link to this

I will be making reservations to show support for a local business. Best of Luck

By verne

November 17, 2006 09:30 AM | Link to this

we love the blue moon, its owners , its wonderful creative cuisine. with all of the choices in the area we have not been as supportive as we should have been. we can correct that. the blue moon will be even more enjoyable with the smoking gone. good luck to the fitzgeralds!!!

By joan

November 17, 2006 09:14 AM | Link to this

My husband and I have been regulars at Eclipse since it opened. As a couple who dines out “eight days a week”, Eclipse is at the top of our “A” list of dining choices. How fortunate we have been to have a restaurant right here in Dayton, Ohio that would rival any big city establishment. How sad that we may lose it…

By Bob

November 17, 2006 09:05 AM | Link to this

We have eaten at Oregon Distric location of Blue Moon a few times in times past and the Centerville location many times since it opened. We have had great service and outstanding meals on all occassions. The only drawback are the prices… then again, you get what you pay for. Beth & Greg, we wish you well.

By Mr. Nugent

November 17, 2006 08:49 AM | Link to this

Time after time again, I’ve seen businesses grow too fast. My suspicion is that the second restaurant did them in. K.I.S.S.: Keep It Simple Stupid! Its a shame because they do have great food and great service. Regarding their martini’s: They are expensive, but one really does do the trick! .

By Travis

November 17, 2006 07:49 AM | Link to this

Dining is a highly personal experience for everyone. One person’s thing is burgers, others foie gras. All I can say is that Blue Moon is one of the few restaurants in Dayton that is consistently creative, well prepared, and always has something new on the menu to entice its diners. To lose these restaurants would truly be a loss to our community. Service is almost a no-miss. The staff is well educated without being snobby and the pace of a meal is near-perfect. Great date-night place!

By John

November 17, 2006 07:34 AM | Link to this

Take the name ‘Blue Moon’ in all the negative comments and replace it with ‘Cheesecake Factory’ ‘Ruby Tuesdays’, etc and you still have the same response. But if you visit those establishments you’ll find packed parking lots! The true reason for the demise of the Blue Moon is that it’s located in downtown Dayton and most middle/upper class Americans avoid anything to do with downtown Dayton. The TOTAL lack of leadership from the business and political community in Dayton adds to the problem.

By Gary

November 17, 2006 06:32 AM | Link to this

I hope we can keep the Blue Moon open with continued patronage. It’d be ashamed to lose a local business that helps give downtown Dayton an edge. It’s one of the special places that gets us downtown.

By Ed

November 17, 2006 06:26 AM | Link to this

I have never eaten at The Blue Moon and therefore have no opinion. Thanks for asking, though.

By Amanda

November 17, 2006 01:23 AM | Link to this

I have never had a meal at the Blue Moon. I have no desire to. After living above the restaurant prior to their expansion into the building next door, I was disgusted with the LARGE cockroaches that came from their portion of the building along with the way in which they seemingly just threw their trash where ever they wanted. I can’t tell you how many times I had to strategically walk around oyster shells to get into my garage.

By Kristy

November 17, 2006 12:26 AM | Link to this

This was my favorite restaurant before I moved to Sacramento. I wish you the best, Beth and Greg.

By Drew

November 17, 2006 12:11 AM | Link to this

I don’t remember ever regretting a visit to Blue Moon. I’m not sure I believe some of these posts. The food is about the best in town. I love the appetizers, the breads, salads, entrees and desserts. Let’s not forget the mandarin/cracked pepper infused vodka! If something is not to your liking then mention it to management. And approach the situation in an adult, businesslike manner. Everyone of us has an off day. Try not to take things personally.Support locally owned businesses.

By M

November 16, 2006 11:16 PM | Link to this

Yeah, I don’t know why people crowd Cheesecake Factory. Went there Thurs. afternoon and had two people at our table — food didn’t come out together — they brought my lunch, but my mother had to wait 10-15 mins. for her dish to come out — and after it did, it was not good — tasted like a bagged pasta one-skillet dinner you buy in the freezer at the grocery. Noise is horrible in that place — constant clinking of dishes all around you and you have to yell to talk. We don’t plan to go back.

By Tyler

November 16, 2006 11:15 PM | Link to this

Support fellow Daytonians, enjoy the best service at the finest bistro in town and experience a truly unique, pleasurable evening from your taste buds to toenails, in historical downtown Dayton…just another visit to the Blue Moon. I’ve been fan for about three years, recommending the experience to friends and family and always looking forward to my next visit before I had even left the Oregon district. Now I work for Blue Moon and it’s easy to work hard for such a renowned, local presence.

By Josh L

November 16, 2006 10:49 PM | Link to this

My wife and I enjoyed Valentines day a year and a half ago at the Blue Moon just before we got married. I have eaten at every decent resteraunt in Dayton, and Blue Moon had by far the best service I have experienced. The food was also top notch. The atmosphere was jazzy and relaxed. I frankly can’t believe anyone would compare the “Cheesecake Factory” to Blue Moon. Cheesecake factory is a horrible value… I’d take Fridays over that joint.

I will make another reservation this week.

By john

November 16, 2006 10:41 PM | Link to this

My wife and I eat out 2-4 times a week. We enjoy a wide range of cuisine.We tried Blue Moon 2 or 3 times many years ago and stopped going back. To our taste the menu had too many “weird” offerings,not many selections appealed to us. Worse, they were overdone with heavy sauces and butter. But the most serious complaint was observing some patrons being treated as obvious regulars, while we were treated as strangers. While BM has its regulars apparently too many others felt the way we did.

By steve

November 16, 2006 10:37 PM | Link to this

I’m curious the quote by Beth Fitzgerald in reference to 9/11 has now been removed from the article by Mark Fisher. How shameful of Jeff Bruce, the editor of the Dayton Daily News to allow such a practice.

By john

November 16, 2006 10:24 PM | Link to this

The Oregon District will not reach its potential until 5th St.is closed to traffic-make it a walking or mall area. At least at night. Why the city of Dayton can’t do this is beyond me. If Blue Moon closes it will decrease business for the other restaurants there and jeopardize the viability of the remaining places. I don’t think many of the patrons at Brio or Cheesecake or PF Chang were customers of Blue Moon, at least enough to be material.

By John

November 16, 2006 09:25 PM | Link to this

I can’t speak for Blue Moon, but Eclipse is wonderful. The food and the service are first rate. We have dined there for many special occasions. It truly saddens me to think that we will lose another local dining establishment. We are considering relocating to Ashville NC, for many reasons —- not the least of which is that almost all of the restaurants there are locally / chef owned. As for snotty servers - send in secret shoppers and get rid of the ones with attitudes.

By Kathy

November 16, 2006 09:24 PM | Link to this

I was very disturbed to hear the news that Blue Moon and formerly the Eclipse, may be closing. Those restaurants are like family to me! Every time I have been there, the food has been delicious and the service has been exceptional. Always a special time. Please show your support to two fine restaurants!

By R

November 16, 2006 09:13 PM | Link to this

Know thy customer. Know the economy. Know that Dayton doesn’t have the cash cow business it once had. Know that even those living outside of Oakwood want a nice dining experience. From one who lives in the land of Darden restaurant headquarters (Olive Garden, Red Lobster, ad nauseum), local fare is what sets you apart. I’ve never had the opportunity to eat at the Blue Moon, but the main stay of restaurant success is to give your patrons what they want. Not necessarily what YOU want.

By chris smyth

November 16, 2006 08:43 PM | Link to this

Our family has eaten at Blue Moon and Eclipse on many occassions. We love the food and the service is amazing. McDonald’s service is better than Blue Moon? I What planet do you live on? I’m wondering when an article is written about a local restaurant closing, why there would be such nasty and cutting remarks made by people. Would you rather support restaurant chains that don’t care about their community or a privately owned resturant where the owners care about giving back to their community.

By Nancy

November 16, 2006 08:19 PM | Link to this

My husband and I have been consistently impressed by the cuisine at Eclipse and Blue Moon. We had been patrons of Blue Moon for several years, and we felt that the food and service was wonderful, and (perhaps after a couple of weeks to get the kinks out of the system) both felt that Eclipse was even better. We’ve recommended Eclipse to many of our friends who have also had wonderful dining experiences. Don’t close!

By Joanne

November 16, 2006 08:16 PM | Link to this

Cities get the restaurants they deserve. Daytonians are reverse snobs. Keeping gems like Blue Moon flourishing requires regular patronage, educating your palate to know the difference between the early bird special at the Longhorn and actual dining, encouragement to experiment (interesting kitchens will have some spectacular failures along with the successes), and, yes, money. I’ll be sorry, but not surprised, to lose another real restaurant to the Curse of the Creeping Cheesecake.

By Pat

November 16, 2006 07:57 PM | Link to this

Blue Moon is my favorite place to dine in Dayton. I always feel pampered by the knowledgeable staff and have never had a bad meal, dessert, or drink (great martinis!) in the years I’ve eaten there. But what do I know? I voted against the city council that brought Beavercreek a true “asphalt jungle” a.k.a. Fairfield Commons Mall and The Greene. Everyone complains about downtown Dayton, yet they refuse to patronize the few gems still in the city. Check the empty store fronts. So sad.

By Larry

November 16, 2006 07:53 PM | Link to this

We don’t eat out as often as we’d like, but when we do, we choose a locally owned restaurant about 98 percent of the time. Unfortunately, not enough people support local businesses of all sorts, and restaurants suffer particularly from genericizing of American expectations. Go to Blue Moon. Go to Coco’s. Go to Jay’s. Go to Cafe Bolevard. Go to C’est Tout. Go to Smokin’. — and on and on. Let Olive Garden, Cheesecake Factory, Panera, etc. be occasional choices, not your first choice.

By Jennifer

November 16, 2006 07:35 PM | Link to this

I have known Beth and Greg for 30 years and their generosity and positive karmic nature (what goes around comes around) makes this hardship seen entirely unfair. These fine people are becoming another casualty of cutbacks in disposable personal and corporate spending (yes, since 911) and of the proliferation of generic chain restaurants with their lower cost of doing business. PLEASE someone buy the good Blue Moon name and maybe even move it to BallPark Village. If you build it they will come.

By Sean

November 16, 2006 07:31 PM | Link to this

I am also saddened by the news of a possible closing. Like many others, I appreciate the great food and service. Unfortunately, most people want chains. Historically, every small business owner with a quality product vs. cheap and common, takes a hit from the big chains. I will continue to dine at the Blue Moon no matter what the outcome.

By Paul

November 16, 2006 07:27 PM | Link to this

As a retired airline employee, I have eaten at local restaurants in major cities all over the world. I seek them out. Do you expect 5 star service in Dayton, Ohio? If you do, and didn’t receive it, did you discreetly approach management to have them correct the problem? Don’t sit there and seeth about it. Allow your host to correct the problem. Calm down, and understand that your next visit will be different. They know you now. Go back, ask for the manager, you will see the difference. Enjoy.

By Jennifer

November 16, 2006 07:26 PM | Link to this

The deplorable and personal attack on Beth and Greg Fitzgerald for “playing the 911 card” should never have been even considered. I have known these fine people for 30 years and they are of such great positive kharmic and generous character it is deplorable to think otherwise. If you ask ANY business owner who depends on disposable family or corporate income for a living they will tell you things are not even yet back to pre 911 levels.