“I miss weddings. I miss funerals. But I’ve never missed Super Bowls,” Eaton said.
Crisman, 82, lives in Kennebunk Beach, Maine, and has been a New England Patriots fan since the franchise’s inception. Eaton, 79, lives in Lansing, Michigan, and is a loyal fan of the Detroit Lions, who have never played in the Super Bowl. Henschel, 77, splits his time between Pittsburgh and Tampa, Florida, and is a longtime Steelers fan. The three met each other after many years of attending Super Bowls.
Related: Photos: Scenes ahead of Super Bowl 53 in Atlanta
It doesn’t matter who’s playing in the big game; these men are always there, as they have been since they were in their 20s.
Henschel’s streak started when he got tickets to the first few Super Bowls from NFL players who frequented a Chicago bar where he worked part-time in the late 1960s. His full-time job was as an airline gate and ticket agent, “so I could fly to the Super Bowl for nothing.”
“After the fourth or fifth one, it became a must-thing for me. I had to go,” Henschel said. “I’ve saved all my ticket stubs, all my programs. ... I’d rather go the Super Bowl than to New Year’s and Fourth of July (celebrations) put together. It’s so much fun.”
Related: Related: Super Bowl LIII: What time, what channel, how to watch
Eaton’s streak began when he got tickets to the first two Super Bowls through a friend, a former Michigan State player, who was in the games with the Green Bay Packers.
“One led to the next and the next. I got on a roll, and I just kept going,” said Eaton, who owns a ground-transportation company, Detroit-based Metro Cars. “It just kind of snowballed.
“Anyone in my family knows not to plan anything that week because I’m gone.”
Tom Henschel, Gregory Eaton and Don Crisman are the remaining members of the Never Miss a Super Bowl Club.
Credit: Hyosub Shin/AJC
Credit: Hyosub Shin/AJC
Because of health problems last summer, Crisman thought he’d miss this trip to Atlanta. “I thought I had seen my last Super Bowl,” Crisman said. “But I have made a comeback.”
Related: Super Bowl commercials 2019: Which companies will pay for spots during big game
In their 53 years of attending Super Bowls, Crisman, Eaton and Henschel have seen ticket prices rise from $12 into the thousands of dollars. In recent years, Crisman and Henschel have bought their tickets directly from the NFL at face value, a privilege afforded them for their longevity. Eaton said he has never gone through the NFL for tickets, getting his through his own contacts.
These Super Bowl regulars certainly didn’t expect in 1967 how massive the event would become.
“The Super Bowl could have been a bust,” said Crisman, whose career was in telecommunications, “if it wasn’t for Joe Namath in Super Bowl III.”
Related: Five of the best Super Bowl commercials of all time
Crisman and Henschel appeared in a Visa commercial in 2010, along with San Francisco 49ers fan Larry Jacobson and Green Bay Packers fan Robert Cook, who had also attended every Super Bowl. Cook died in 2011 and Jacobson died in 2017. Crisman and Henschel met Eaton at Super Bowl LI in Houston, and Friday's lunch started their annual reunion.
“God bless us,” Eaton said as he warmly greeted Henschel. “We made it another year.”