The defense’s argument “lacks merit” and is “not barred by the double jeopardy clause” of trying defendant twice on the same crime, Langer’s ruling states.
RELATED: ‘Quirky’ law may return Kettering teen shooting death case to juvenile court
Gregory is set to be retried May 13.
A jury in November found Gregory guilty of two counts of reckless homicide and one count of discharging a firearm. It also found itself deadlocked on five felonious assault charges in what was Kettering’s first gun-related homicide since 2007.
But Gregory’s attorneys said the retrial should not go forward.
“The jury’s finding of guilt as to the reckless homicide charge amounted to a de facto acquittal on the felonious assault charges,” according to a motion filed by defense attorney Ben Swift.
RELATED: ‘It felt like Ronnie died all over again:’ Kettering shooting victim’s mother speaks out on verdict
Gregory and Bowers were both 16 at the time of the shooting, and the defendant’s case was initially heard in juvenile court before a 2017 mandatory transfer to adult court.
Gregory was indicted on — and pleaded not guilty to — two counts of murder, five counts of felonious assault and the firearms charge.
Because Gregory was convicted of charges that did not require mandatory transfers to adult court, the case will return to juvenile court, Langer has ruled.
RELATED: Kettering murder trial: Six things to know about the jury
In that court, Gregory could face a lighter sentence, officials have said.
After a retrial on the remaining felonious assault counts, Gregory would face sentencing in adult court on all charges for which he has been convicted – with that punishment being stayed – while the case goes back to juvenile court, Langer has said.
-MORE COVERAGE ON THIS ISSUE:
RELATED: Kettering murder case jury convicts teen on lesser charges
RELATED: Kettering teen accused of murder testifies in his own defense
RELATED: 9 key players in Kettering murder case stemming from 2016 killing of Fairmont student
RELATED: How Kettering teen came to be tried as adult and what took case 2 years to go to trial
RELATED: Kettering murder trial starts more than 2 years after fatal shooting
RELATED: Kettering teen indicted on adult charges in homicide of Fairmont student
About the Author