John Dillinger was arrested in Dayton Sept. 22, 1933.

The time infamous gangster John Dillinger was arrested in Dayton after he was drawn here by romance

“Public Enemy No. 1” was sitting in a Dayton jail cell 85 years ago.

Guarded by officers armed with rifles and shotguns, John Dillinger, 30, suspected as “the leader of bandits,” was captured in a boarding house on West First Street.

Found in the boarding house were “four pistols, $2,600 in cash, quantities of rifle and shotgun shells, detailed notes explaining the speediest ways to escape from various cities and sacks full of carpet tacks,” according to a story published in the Sept. 22, 1933 edition of the Dayton Daily News.

 

MORE GANGSTERS IN DAYTON
Bugs Moran and the summer he entranced the city

Police said the tacks were to be scattered over highways to "puncture tires of autos in pursuit. This was done in six holdups.”

Paroled from an Indiana prison the previous May, Dillinger, along with a handful of triggermen, zig zagged across Indiana and Ohio holding up six banks, including one in New Carlisle.

In 1933 John Dillinger,along with a handful of triggermen, zig zagged across Indiana and Ohio holding up six banks including the New New Carlisle National Bank. DAYTON DAILY NEWS ARCHIVE
Photo: file art

It was estimated the group got away with more than $50,000.

True love lured Dillinger to Dayton, according to a 2009 Dayton Daily News story.

Mary Longnecker, 23, the sister of one of Dillinger’s fellow Indiana inmates, was living in the Gem City.

An American bank robber during the Depression, John Dillinger escaped jail twice. Dillinger became "Public Enemy No. 1" on the FBI’s most wanted list. He was killed by federal agents in Chicago July 22, 1934.
Photo: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Enticed by the stories his prison pal told, Dillinger traveled to Dayton eager to meet Longnecker. Driving down West First Street in a Model A Ford, he yelled out the window at pedestrians asking the whereabouts of the young woman.

A romance developed and Dillinger visited Longnecker at her boarding house over the summer months.

The gumshoes with Pinkerton National Detective Agency learned about the robber's romance.

“Dillinger calls upon this woman regularly and, no doubt, can be apprehended at Dayton, Ohio,” wrote a manager for the agency to S.E. Yendes, Dayton chief of detectives.

 

MORE THROWBACK THURSDAY» The day Charles Kettering earned the paperwork that helped change the world» Dayton's 'handsome palace' of the 1900s» When Abraham Lincoln spoke at the old courthouse» 15 reasons this Wright brothers celebration was Dayton's biggest party ever

The landlady at the boarding house was in cahoots with the police and let them know the next time Dillinger blew into town. At 1 a.m., the Dayton police, led by Yendes, burst into the room.

“Dillinger was found in bed. He made no resistance,” the 1933 story reported.

Days later, the newspaper reported authorities in three states were “fighting for possession of John Dillinger.” 

Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Robert C. Patterson turned Dillinger over to armed guards, who escorted the gangster to Allen County to await trial for robbing the Citizens National Bank in Bluffton.

Dillinger’s gang escaped from their Indiana prison and made their way to Allen County. They passed themselves off as prison officials and broke Dillinger out of jail, killing Sheriff Jesse Sarber during the escape.

Dillinger became "Public Enemy No. 1" on the FBI’s most wanted list. He was killed by federal agents in Chicago July 22, 1934.

Thank you for reading the Dayton Daily News and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to exclusive deals and newsletters.

Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Dayton Daily News. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.

X