UPDATE: Coroner IDs victims of West Chester quadruple homicide

Credit: DaytonDailyNews

Combined ShapeCaption
Ohio BCI Divers search pond at apartment complex where four people were found dead in West Chester

Credit: DaytonDailyNews

UPDATE @ 3:57 p.m.

The Butler County coroner’s office has released the identifications of the four found killed in a West Chester apartment on Sunday night.

- Shalinderjit Kaur, female, 39

- Amarjit Kaur, female, 58

- Parmjit Kaur, female, 62

- Hakiakat Singh Pannag, male, 59

All four were ruled homicides by gunshot wounds. The time of death for each is listed as 9:50 p.m.

Credit: DaytonDailyNews

Combined ShapeCaption
???Police believe that a shooter who killed four members of a family in a West Chester Twp. apartment is not among the dead, West Chester Twp. police Chief Joel Herzog said during a news conference today.

Credit: DaytonDailyNews


A Bureau of Criminal Investigation dive team has left the Lakefront at West Chester apartments after performing a search on Tuesday, two days after four people were found dead at one of the apartments in the complex.

The crew was seen by our reporter searching a pond behind the apartment where the three female and one male family members were discovered after another family member returned home, found them and called 911.


• What happened in the first 24 hours

• Residents, religious leaders and officials react with shock

• PHOTOS: 4 bodies found in West Chester apartment

A neighbor said he saw the team pull an item from the pond.

“I could see them holding something, but their body was between me and (the item),” said Rick Karvosky, who lives in the complex. “I could just see them carrying something up to the shore and put it in a white bucket.”


The Indian Minister of External Affairs tweeted on Tuesday that the victims included “an Indian national on a visit to US while others were persons of Indian origin” and that the incident “is not a hate crime.”

A West Chester spokesperson also released a statement on Tuesday that indicated the township has received many questions about the victims’ faith and nationality but that “there is no reason to believe that this is a hate crime.”

Police have not provided any other updates today, but chief Joel Herzog said on Monday that all four appeared to suffer gunshot wounds but his department didn’t believe anyone else was in danger.

A large police response followed the discovery on Sunday night at about 9:40 p.m., and officials said they were searching for a suspect. They said they had not identified a suspect, but there were multiple people they wanted to talk to.

Martin Schneider, administrator for the Butler County Coroner's Office, said this morning the office is continuing to contact next of kin for those found dead. Some family members that office is required to notify are from out of the country, he said.

About the Authors