This hometown cafe has some INCREDIBLE history -- and a menu of comfort food, to boot

Credit: Alex Perry

Credit: Alex Perry

On a chilly Wednesday, I was on a hunt for comfort food. Having just ran through New Carlisle, I thought back to my feature on the town's must-visit spots, and opted for the highly-rated Stagecoach Cafe for lunch.

On the outside, the building looks like most in town. Tall, slightly narrow, clearly home to a unique history. I parked in the lot behind the cafe -- a convenient option for anyone with kids, or elderly, to avoid the street.

>> What to see, what to do and what to love in the quaint town of New Carlisle

I was immediately welcomed by owner Andrea Wallingford Barr, and found myself a seat. The first things I took in was the banter of the patrons, the decor -- I believe my mother in law refers to it as “primitive” -- and the smell. Mmmm, what could that be? I was definitely hungry at this point.

>> This Butler County dining spot is now open today for a special preview 

Credit: Alex Perry

Credit: Alex Perry

>> Make this year unforgettable -- your 2018 Dayton bucket list 
I decided to order the daily special, which was soup beans with ham and cornbread. The name alone felt comforting. I also added a chef salad, which was much bigger than I expected.

>> No retirement in sight: 5 reasons why we’ll still be working past retirement age

Just as I’d hoped, the cornbread with the warm bowl of beans, onions and ham brought me immediate comfort. The salad freshened up the palate, and I appreciated the fact it was made with artisan lettuce versus a bagged blend. You can always tell when the lettuce is fresh, hand-cut versus pre-packaged with tasteless onions and carrots.

>> 10 restaurants opening soon that we can’t wait to try 

Credit: Alex Perry

Credit: Alex Perry

>> Hocking Hills to open new John Glenn Astronomy Park for the summer solstice 

As I ate, I spoke with Barr and other guests about the cafe -- formerly a residence, church, bank, and as the name tells, a stagecoach stop. I learned one of their regulars, a man named Dewie, would be celebrating his 97th birthday the next day. Barr told me stories about Dewie as a WWII fighter pilot and how he found John Dillinger's getaway car off Union Road just outside of town. Abe's Hidden Treasures in New Carlisle was formerly a bank, and the first top Dillinger made in his bank-robbing escapade that began just north of Dayton.

>> These beefy burgers are well worth the drive down I-70 to try one

Credit: Alex Perry

Credit: Alex Perry

>> Need a laugh? Don’t miss the Rubi Girls, comedians at comedy bash this weekend

By this point, I was done with my food but I stayed for the conversation. I was fascinated by the stories of local mobsters, a hidden speakeasy, businesses of the past, and other artifacts of the town’s history.

>> 5 tips for boosting your retirement savings

I couldn’t stay much longer as I had to run to another assignment, but after this pleasant experience -- both knowledge and food -- I have to say I’ll be coming back around again soon. There’s more menu to try and more history to learn, after all.

>> Upgrade your yard by visiting these Dayton-area greenhouses 

Credit: Alex Perry

Credit: Alex Perry

Want to go?

WHAT: Stagecoach Cafe

WHERE: 120 W. Jefferson St., New Carlisle

HOURS: 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. Tuesday-Saturday

CONTACT: Call 937-679-5282

About the Author