A Miami County man convicted of murder could get a new trial based on a complaint that a juror told others in deliberations that he had never seen the accused in the church that both men said they attended.
A federal judge ordered an evidentiary hearing on a claim of juror misconduct in the 2014 murder trial of Patrick McGail of Troy, one of three young men convicted in the 2013 shooting death of Nathan Wintrow of Troy.
McGail is serving a term of 24 years to life in the London Correctional Institution. He was convicted in August 2014 of murder, aggravated robbery and aggravated burglary.
“I will adamantly oppose any attempt to bail him out in the event he is granted a new trial,” Miami County Prosecutor Tony Kendell said Tuesday afternoon after a conference.
That conference included Kendell, Common Pleas Judge Christopher Gee, who presided over the trial and sentenced McGail, and Eric Eches of Cincinnati, a lawyer for McGail.
Gee set the evidentiary hearing for Jan. 25.
Tuesday’s hearing followed a Nov. 14 decision by Judge Walter Rice in U.S. District Court in Dayton on an action filed on McGail’s behalf in the federal court.
Rice, in his order, granted “a conditional writ of habeas corpus, requiring the petitioner (McGail) be discharged from custody unless he is given a prompt evidentiary hearing, not later than 90 days from date, in the Miami County Common Pleas Court on his claim of juror misconduct.”
McGail’s lawyers claimed he was deprived of his constitutional rights to an impartial jury and to confront evidence against him. They claimed this occurred when a juror, according to a juror’s affidavit, told others deliberating in the case that he attended the same church as McGail and that he had never seen McGail or his family at the church.
In his testimony, McGail, then 18, talked about his family and their church activities.
“My decision was influenced to vote ‘guilty’ when the jury foreman … told the jury that he goes to St. Patrick’s church, the same church that McGail testified going to, and that he had never seen Patrick or his family at that church, so McGail must be lying,” the juror wrote in the affidavit, according to the federal court’s ruling. “This information influenced me to not believe Patrick’s testimony.”
Rice said the evidentiary hearing should look at what the jury foreman said about McGail and/or his family’s church involvement and its impact on the jury and its members. Rice asked to be notified of the hearing results.
“Because testimony concerning McGail’s church involvement was obviously used to establish his good character and bolster his credibility with the jury … the importance of the foreman stating privately to the jury that he ‘goes to St. Patrick’s church’ but that ‘he had never seen Patrick or his family at that church, so he must be lying’ cannot be overstated,” Rice wrote.
The affidavit claiming juror misconduct was filed as part of motions with the local court after the trial and was included in decisions by both the local court and the 2nd District Court of Appeals to uphold the conviction. The Ohio Supreme Court did not accept McGail’s case on appeal. The federal court request was filed in 2017.
Troy police said Wintrow died after being shot in October 2013 in his home on Canal Street in Troy. Also convicted in the death were Brandon Terrel, who was sentenced to 14 years, and Jason Sowers, who shot Wintrow and was sentenced to 18 years to life. They testified against McGail.
Thank you for reading the Dayton Daily News and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to exclusive deals and newsletters.
Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Dayton Daily News. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.