Troopers reportedly attempted to stop Poindexter for speeding around 1:10 a.m. on I-75 north of Piqua.
While he initially stopped, Poindexter took off toward the city as troopers approached and he exited the highway.
He re-entered I-75 outside of Troy and hit road spikes.
The car went into a ditch and then hit the right of way fence, disabling the vehicle.
The 51-year-old allegedly got out of the car with something in his hand and did not comply with orders from a trooper.
TRENDING: Pike County murder suspect booked in Butler County jail
The trooper fired several rounds, but none of them hit Poindexter, according to the highway patrol.
Poindexter ran from the scene, but was caught at the Honda Center on Stanfield Road in Troy after a quick foot chase.
After being discharged from an area hospital, he tried to flee but was arrested.
OTHER LOCAL NEWS: Coroner's called to crash in Dayton
A trooper was injured after he was hit in the face, authorities said.
Poindexter was scheduled to be in Miami County court Tuesday.
Got a tip? Call our monitored 24-hour line, 937-259-2237, or send it to firstname.lastname@example.org