Kevin Foster, the dog’s owner’s father, said there were several incorrect facts during the testimony and he’s worried the tension among the neighbors may escalate.
“One of these families probably will be on the news soon,” Foster told this news agency after the preliminary hearing. “Whether he comes at me and whatever happens, that’s disgusting. That’s disgusting that it has to come to this.”
Foster said there were inconsistencies with the testimony from his neighbor, Brad Sorrell, who was called by Miller’s attorney, Thomas Manning. Sorrell testified that he saw Ruger in Miller’s yard, so he alerted Miller. He saw Miller leave his house with a baseball bat, then hit the dog once as the dog was coming toward him, he testified.
Sorrell said he then returned to his yard so he didn’t see if Miller hit the dog more than once.
MORE: Middletown woman facing charges after 6 dogs reported fighting, found in poor conditions
But Butler County Deputy Dog Warden Jamie Hearlihy testified Miller told her he “beat the F” out of the dog. Later, she testified, Miller said he couldn’t remember how many times he hit the dog.
Originally, Miller was charged with a misdemeanor, then Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones increased the charge to a fifth-degree felony, Hearlihy testified.
Manning called the dog’s death an “unfortunate situation.” He said Miller “used what he could” to protect him from the dog.
He said Miller was innocent of the charge because he used “self-defense action.”