2023 Battle of the Bartenders winners announced

Wheat Penny chef Nicholas Cheng, sous chef Hannah Cranmer, bar manager Thomas Morris and chef and co-owner Liz Valenti receive a Buckeye Vodka gift basket from Jim Finke from Buckeye Vodka. Wheat Penny's cocktail, "Stop and Smell the Roses," was made with rose hip, black tea and cardamom infused vodka with punt e mes (an Italian vermouth), housemade orgeat, lemon, grapefruit, Earl Gray tea and rose water topped off with a sea salt foam took home top prize.

Credit: Alexis Larsen

Credit: Alexis Larsen

Wheat Penny chef Nicholas Cheng, sous chef Hannah Cranmer, bar manager Thomas Morris and chef and co-owner Liz Valenti receive a Buckeye Vodka gift basket from Jim Finke from Buckeye Vodka. Wheat Penny's cocktail, "Stop and Smell the Roses," was made with rose hip, black tea and cardamom infused vodka with punt e mes (an Italian vermouth), housemade orgeat, lemon, grapefruit, Earl Gray tea and rose water topped off with a sea salt foam took home top prize.

Buckeye Vodka Battle of the Bartenders crowned its eighth champion March 8 with much fanfare.

Liz Valenti, Wheat Penny chef and co-owner, and her hugely talented kitchen team were named the new champions for their truly excellent cocktail. Named “Stop and Smell the Roses,” the cocktail was made with rose hip, black tea and cardamom infused vodka with punt e mes (an Italian vermouth), housemade orgeat, lemon, grapefruit, Earl Gray tea and rose water topped off with a sea salt foam.

The drink was conceived by bar manager Thomas Morris. The wonderful dish accompanying it — an herb salad with cold poached shrimp, pickled cherry and pistachio gremolata garnished with slivers of Fresno chiles — was executed by the kitchen team of sous chef Hannah Cranmer and chef Nicholas Cheng.

Left to right: Wheat Penny's winning team from 2023 Buckeye Vodka Battle of the Bartenders: Wheat Penny chef and co-owner Liz Valenti, chef Nicholas Cheng, bar manager Thomas Morris and sous chef Hannah Cranmer.

Credit: Alexis Larsen

icon to expand image

Credit: Alexis Larsen

“This was the ultimate team building project,” said Valenti of the win. “Collaboration, inspiration and hard, rewarding work. I am so proud of our entire Wheat Penny family.”

It’s the third win for Wheat Penny and the first for this team.

The staff joins an impressive list of past Battle of the Bartenders winners:

2020: Roland Eliason, The Winds “Gold Blooded”

2019: Carolyn Porter, Wheat Penny “Dutchess of Earl”

2018: Brock McKibben, Wheat Penny " Merchant’s Wife”

2017: Bill Castro, El Meson “Tamiami Miami”

2016: Nikolaus Hunt, Coco’s Bistro “Coco’s Ruby Slipper”

2015: Amber Brady, Lily’s Bistro “Rosemary’s Babee”

2014: Dustin Wade, Meadowlark “The Root of All Evil”

The People’s Choice prize went to an equally tasty winner...

The cocktail from Smiths’ Boathouse restaurant in Troy, “Down the Rabbit Hole,” was conceived and mixed by talented bartender Nicole Wilson.

The carrot based cocktail had wonderful layers of flavor to it thanks to a cilantro infused vodka, passion fruit puree, fennel liqueur, honey, chili powder and a dash of Tabasco topped with a green tomato foam.

The cocktail from Smiths’ Boathouse restaurant in Troy, “Down the Rabbit Hole,” was conceived and mixed by talented bartender Nicole Wilson. The carrot based cocktail had wonderful layers of flavor to it thanks to a cilantro infused vodka, passion fruit puree, fennel liquor, honey, chili powder and a dash of tabasco topped with a green tomato foam.

Credit: Alexis Larsen

icon to expand image

Credit: Alexis Larsen

Sound weird?

Yes, to us too, but the resulting cocktail was an absolutely delicious mix of sweet, citrus spice that danced on taste buds winning the crowd and this judge over.

Other runners up for the top prize at the sold out event held at the Steam Plant downtown were Carvers Steaks and Chops with a hibiscus based cocktail and Rip Rap Roadhouse with a coconut and raspberry martini.

Dayton Eats looks at the regional food stories and restaurant news that make mouths water. Menu updates, special dinners and events, new chefs, interesting new dishes and culinary adventures. Do you know of new exciting format changes, specials, happy hours, restaurant updates or any other tasty news you think is worth a closer look at? E-mail Alexis Larsen at alexis.e.larsen@hotmail.com with the information and we will work to include it in future coverage.

About the Author