All the ‘best hamburger’ restaurants nominated during Best of Dayton 2025

Northstar Café’s cheeseburger made from Niman Ranch brisket and chuck, ground in-house daily, topped with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle served with housemade sweet potato chips.

Credit: Nick Graham

Credit: Nick Graham

Northstar Café’s cheeseburger made from Niman Ranch brisket and chuck, ground in-house daily, topped with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle served with housemade sweet potato chips.

Are you looking for the best hamburger in the Dayton region?

Here’s a look at the nominations for Best Hamburger in our 2025 Best of Dayton contest.

Nominations include:

  • Airline Dairy Creme, 224 N. Dixie Dr. in Vandalia
  • Alematic Artisan Ales, 6182 Chambersburg Road in Huber Heights
  • Angry Chicken House, 504 Central Ave. in Carlisle
  • Archer’s Tavern, 9496 Dayton Lebanon Pike in Centerville or 2030 E. Dorothy Lane in Kettering
  • Arrow Queen, 431 N. Main St. in New Carlisle
  • Bagger Dave’s, 5299 Cornerstone N. Blvd. in Centerville
  • The Bank House Cafe, 123 E. Main St. in Verona
  • Benjamin’s the Burger Master, 1000 N. Main St. Dayton
  • Bennett’s Publical Family Sports Grill, 67 S. Main St. in Miamisburg
  • Between the Bunz LLC, a food truck based in Springfield
  • Blind Bob’s, 430 E. Fifth St. in Dayton
  • Bourbons Craft Kitchen & Bar, 2231 N. Verity Parkway in Middletown
  • Brookville Grille, 428 N. Wolf Creek St. #2 in Brookville
  • The Brunch Club, 601 S. Main St. in Dayton
  • The Brunch Pub, 101 W. Franklin St. in Centerville
  • Buckeye Burgers, a food truck based in West Milton
  • Bullpen, inside Dot’s Market at 2274 Patterson Road in Dayton
  • Bullwinkle’s Top Hat Bistro, 199 N. Main St. in Miamisburg
  • Bunkers Sports Bar & Grill, 893 E. National Road in Vandalia
  • Butterbee’s American Grille, 217 Progress Drive in Xenia
  • Capri Bowling Lanes, 2727 S. Dixie Drive in Kettering
  • Carmichael’s Pub, 3011 Wayne Ave. in Dayton
  • Carvers Steaks & Chops, 1535 Miamisburg Centerville Road in Washington Twp.
  • Chappy’s Social House, 7880 Washington Village Drive in Washington Twp.
  • Charlies Deli & Catering, 429 Troy St. in Dayton
  • The Chop House, 7727 Washington Village Drive in Washington Twp.
  • Christopher’s Restaurant & Catering, a catering company based in Dayton
  • Cherry House Cafe, 1241 Meadow Bridge Drive in Beavercreek
  • Chicago Gyros & Dogs, 3979 Indian Ripple Road in Beavercreek
  • Chili’s, 1110 Miamisburg Centerville Road in Washington Twp. or 2762 N. Fairfield Road in Beavercreek
  • Club Oceano Seafood & Bar, 4429 Cedar Park Drive in Beavercreek
  • Coco’s Bistro, 250 Warren St. in Dayton
  • Company 7 BBQ, 1001 S. Main St. in Englewood
  • Coopers Hawk Winery & Restaurant, 5220 Cornerstone N. Blvd. in Centerville,
  • Crabill’s Hamburger Shoppe, 727 Miami St. in Urbana
  • Crooked Handle Brewing Co., 123 N. Main St. in Piqua or 760 N .Main St. in Springboro
  • CULTURE, 416 E. Fifth St. in Dayton
  • Culver’s, 6425 Miller Lane in Dayton
  • D’s Birria and More, 1015 S. Main St. in Miamisburg
  • Dad’s Wings and Burgers, 2638 Colonel Glenn Highway in Fairborn
  • Dorothy Lane Market (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Doubleday’s Grill &Tavern, 101 E Alex Bell Road #120 in Centerville and 776 N. Main St. in Springboro
  • Elsa’s Mexican Restaurants (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Eudora Brewing Company, 3022 Wilmington Pike in Kettering
  • The Famous Restaurant, 953 S. Main St. in Centerville
  • Firebirds Wood Fired Grill, 3500 Rigby Road in Miami Twp.
  • Five Guys (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • The Florentine Restaurant, 21 W. Market St. in Germantown
  • The Food Pitt, a food truck based in Dayton
  • The Foundry, inside the AC Hotel at 124 Madison St. in Dayton
  • Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Geez Grill & Pub, 6061 Far Hills Ave. in Centerville
  • George’s Family Restaurant, 5216 N. Dixie Drive in Dayton
  • Halal Burgers (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Hamburger Wagon, 12 E. Central Ave. in Miamisburg
  • Hanks Local, 2529 Patterson Road in Dayton
  • Heavenly Hotdogs, a hot dog cart based in Miamisburg
  • Hickory Bar-B-Q, 1082 Brown St. in Dayton
  • Home Sweet Home Cafe, 320 W. National Road #6 in Englewood
  • J. Alexander’s Restaurant, 7970 Washington Village Drive in Washington Twp.
  • Jasper Kitchen + Bar, 1100 Knoll Haven Road in Xenia
  • Jimmie’s Ladder 11, 936 Brown St. in Dayton
  • Koji Burger, inside Jollity at 127 E. Third St. in Dayton
  • K’s Hamburger Shop, 117 E. Main St. in Troy
  • Kings Table Bar & Grill, 2348 Grange Hall Road in Beavercreek
  • Laff’s, 2 E. Center St. in Germantown
  • Lily’s, 329 E. Fifth St. in Dayton
  • Little Fish Brewing Company, 116 Webster St. in Dayton
  • Little York Tavern & Pizza, 4120 Little York Road in Dayton
  • Long Shots Restaurant & Driving Range, 2315 S. Co Road 25A in Troy
  • Loose Ends Brewing, 890 S. Main St. in Centerville
  • Lucky’s Taproom & Eatery, 520 E. Fifth St. in Dayton
  • MacKenzie River, 2739 Fairfield Commons in Beavercreek
  • McNasty’s, a food truck serving the Dayton area
  • Meadowlark Restaurant, 5531 Far Hills Ave. in Dayton
  • Meridien, 28 W. Franklin St. in Centerville
  • Moe Harrigan’s Tavern, 4070 Marshall Road in Kettering
  • Narco Burger, 605 Spinning Road in Riverside
  • Nick’s Restaurant, 1443 N. Detroit St. in Xenia
  • The Oakwood Club, 2414 Far Hills Ave. in Oakwood
  • Ohio Renaissance Festival, 10542 E. State Route 73 in Waynesville
  • Our Place, 6068 W. Third St. in Dayton
  • The Paragon Supper Club, 797 Miamisburg Centerville Road in Washington Twp.
  • The Pine Club, 1926 Brown St. in Dayton
  • Rip Rap Roadhouse, 6024 Rip Rap Road in Dayton

  • The Root Beer Stande, 1727 Woodman Drive in Dayton
  • Rum Runners Cafe, 2318 E. Dorothy Lane in Kettering
  • Sea Jax Tavern, 5900 Bigger Road in Kettering
  • Silas Creative Kitchen, 21 W. Main St. in Versailles
  • Slyder’s Taven, 836 Watervliet Ave. in Dayton
  • Smashburger (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Station House Restaurant, inside The Franciscan Center at 8200 Provincial Way in Centerville
  • Steak ‘n Shake (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Stone House Tavern, 258 S. Main St. in Waynesville
  • Sunrise Cafe, 259 Xenia Ave. in Yellow Springs
  • Texas Roadhouse (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • TJ Chumps (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Trail Town Brewing, 101 Corry St. in Yellow Springs
  • Treasure Island Supper Club, 4250 Chief Woods Lane in Moraine
  • The Trolley Stop, 530 E. Fifth St. Dayton
  • 571 Grill & Draft House, 12389 Milton Carlisle Road in New Carlisle
  • The Ugly Duckling, 1430 E. Fifth St. in Dayton
  • Vinny’s Bar & Grill, 2208 Dryden Road in Moraine
  • Wandering Griffin Brewery & Restaurant, 3725 Presidential Drive in Beavercreek
  • Warped Wing Brewing Company (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Wendy’s (multiple locations in the Dayton region)
  • Wheat Penny Oven and Bar, 515 Wayne Ave. in Dayton
  • White Lotus, 327 E. Third St. in Dayton
  • World Piece, a food truck based in Springboro
  • Wot-A-Dog, 603 S. Main St. in New Carlisle

Last year, Slyder’s Tavern took home first place with McNasty’s Food Truck and The Bank House Café as finalists.

About the Author