Big sale fails to materialize

Springfield News-Sun Reporter Everdeen Mason supplied information for this article

NEW CARLISLE, Ohio--The part of the auction at the former Tecumseh YMCA most people came to see never happened.

The building and its contents went on the block Thursday morning. While there was plenty of buying of things like gym, office, basketball and building maintenance equipment , no one bid when the auctioneer started the sale of the property at $150, 000. After unsuccessfully prodding the crowd, he finally announced, "the good news is, the property is still for sale."

The 34,000-square-foot building sits on 5.9 acres within the city limits.

Prior to the sale, Steve Thompson, president of Thompson Auctioneers and Ohio Real Estate Auction representative, said “we think the building ought to bring $300,000 to $500,000.”  “It ought to sell for more than that, but we’re in a tough economy right now, and a building like this will take a lot of money to get it up to speed.”

Proceeds from the sale will go toward more than $1 million owed to PNC Bank, which loaned the former Y $1.2 million in 2009 to build its new aquatic center. After defaulting on the loan, the Y fell into receivership. The Turner Foundation, which agreed to help the former Y with the loan on a limited basis, is now being held responsible for the debt.

Lake Avenue Christian Church was in line to purchase the building last year for $305,000, hoping to turn the facility into a church and community center. That amount is less than a third of the debt, so Clark County Common Pleas Court ordered an appraisal to determine the true value of the complex on the Turner Foundation’s behalf. The property was appraised for $360,000 in November.

Lake Avenue Pastor Randy Warner said the court order and subsequent appraisal “sent up some red flags.” He said after discussing matters with the congregation, they decided not to pursue the building further.

Meanwhile, the Turner Foundation is embroiled in a legal battle with PNC Bank over the $1.2 million loan. A court date has not yet been scheduled, according to the Common Pleas Court. Calls to Matthew Sorg, court appointed receiver, and Turner Foundation attorney Glen Collier were not returned.

About the Author