Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

Girls basketball: No. 1 Carroll rebounds, dodges Fairmont in double-OT

Unbeaten and No. 1 in the state in Division II, Carroll’s unblemished cruise through the girls high school basketball regular season was derailed by a 13-point loss to visiting Beavercreek last week.

“We took that loss pretty hard,” assured Carroll senior Liz Bush. “That was a humbling experience. We did some team bonding and worked extra hard in practice.”

»» RELATED: Former Trotwood blur in hall of fame

»» RELATED: No. 1 CJ hosts No. 1 Moeller

Pushed to the limit, Carroll rebounded from that loss to stun host Fairmont 64-60 in double overtime at Trent Arena on Monday night.

Kierra Thornton of Fairmont (with ball) avoids Ava Lickliter of Carroll. Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double-OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

It was a non-league matchup of two of the area’s best girls programs. Carroll (16-1) dropped to No. 2 in the state poll that was released on Tuesday. Any doubt the Patriots weren’t worthy of a No. 1 seed in the upcoming sectional was erased by beating Fairmont.

»» FACEBOOK: For more sports you should like Marc Pendleton

»» TWITTER: You should like @MarcPendleton

Fairmont (11-7) is tasked with righting itself after losing three of four games following a seven-game win streak. That includes a 50-43 setback at Pickerington Central, the state’s No. 1 team in D-I. That will be a challenge. Up next for Fairmont is visiting Centerville (17-1) on Saturday night also at Trent. The Greater Western Ohio Conference National East rival Elks soared to No. 2 in the D-I state poll.

Elisabeth Bush of Carroll (with ball) draws Fairmont defenders Madison Bartley (22), Maddy Westbeld and Kierra Thornton. Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

The girls basketball tournament draws are Sunday. Carroll’s top spot is secured in D-II, as is Centerville in D-I. After that, Fairmont, Wayne, Beavercreek and Tecumseh should contend for high D-I seeds.

“We’ll keep plugging away and hopefully everything’s ready to go by tournament time,” said first-year Fairmont coach Jeremey Finn.

»» RELATED: Boys state basketball polls

»» RELATED: Trotwood wears out Sidney in 4th quarter

Carroll converted free throws for its final seven points of the second OT. Julia Keller’s first of three free throws pushed Carroll ahead for good and Bush added two more in the final 13.7 seconds to clinch the clutch win. Keller led Carroll with 17 points. Bush added 14 points and Allie Stafanek 12.

Fairmont led 14-3 in the first quarter but trailed by three at halftime. Maddy Westbeld led Fairmont with 18 points. Mali Morgan-Elliott and Makira Webster each added 12 and Madison Bartley 10. Webster also had three 3-pointers.

Fairmont’s Mallory Hullinger (left), Julia Keller of Carroll and Madison Bartley of Fairmont contend for a rebound. Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double-OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

“When you don’t play your best and you lose, that’s very disappointing,” Carroll coach Cecelia Grosselin said. “But, it exposes weaknesses. We saw things we needed to get better on. We play a tough schedule. To play Fairmont this close to the tournament is just great for our team. It just makes us better. We approached the game that way.”

»» PHOTOS: Trotwood-Madison at Sidney boys hoop

»» PHOTOS: Trotwood-Madison at Tippecanoe girls hoop

This is the fifth straight season the teams have played, with Carroll holding a 3-2 advantage. Fairmont blasted Carroll 60-38 in Game 3 last season. Fairmont owns a decisive height advantage over most opponents with Bartley (6 feet 3), Westbeld (6-2) and Morgan-Elliott (6-0). Keller is Carroll’s tallest at 6 feet.

Elisabeth Bush of Carroll (with ball) is checked by Fairmont defender Madison Bartley. Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

“We knew (Fairmont) was going to be big and rebound good,” Bush said. “We worked really hard for this. We didn’t let the pressure of double overtime get to us.”

»» RELATED: Unbeaten Waynesville follows its leader

»» RELATED: Beavercreek hands Carroll girls first loss

Beavercreek 77, Springfield 34: Taylor Steinbrunner had 14 points and Maci Rhoades and Alyssa Hargrove-Hall added 13 apiece to pace the streaking Beavers (12-6), who won their eighth straight. GWOC scoring leader Mickayla Perdue had 22 points for visiting Springfield (8-9).

Kierra Thornton of Fairmont (with ball) avoids Ava Lickliter of Carroll. Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double-OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

Waynesville 48, Monroe 42: The unbeaten Spartans (16-0) withstood a strong challenge from the host Hornets (10-6). Leah Butterbaugh and Lynzie Hartshorn each scored 11 for Waynesville, which dropped to No. 4 in the D-III state poll.

Bellbrook 50, Miamisburg 43: Mara Mescher led host Bellbrook (9-9) with 13 points and Kayla Paul added 12. Anna Long paced Miamisburg (6-12) with 14 points.

»» RELATED: 5 top boys and girls games

»» RELATED: Trotwood girls outlast Tipp

Milton-Union 44, Tri-County North 25: Kristen Dickison had 29 points with five rebounds and six steals for the host Bulldogs (11-5).

Maddy Westbeld of Fairmont (with ball) scored a game-high 18 points. Carroll defeated host Fairmont 64-60 in double OT in a girls high school basketball game at Trent Arena on Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. MARC PENDLETON / STAFF

Sidney boys 65, Wapakoneta 61: Virginia Tech commit Andre Gordon scored 42 points and became Sidney’s boys all-time career points leader on Monday. He passed the mark of 1,745 points set by Dewayne McCluskey in 1988. Gordon’s pair of free throws with three seconds to play sealed the win for host Sidney (12-3). Ratez Roberts, Sidney’s all-time leader in rebounds, surpassed 500 for his career.

»» FOOTBALL: New coach at Fairborn

»» RELATED: Girls basketball state polls

Houston 53, Newton 52: John Leist hit the game-winning free throws with 1.9 seconds left, finishing with 19 points to lead host Houston (3-12). Ryan Mollette scored 17 points for Newton.

»» PHOTOS: Flyin’ to the Hoop, Day 3

»» PHOTOS: Flyin’ to the Hoop, Day 2

»» FLYIN’: Another memorable moment

»» RELATED: Boys state hoop polls

»» PHOTOS: Flyin’ to the Hoop, Day 1

»» FLYIN’ GAME 15: Ball in the Family a Flyin’ hit

Thank you for reading the Dayton Daily News and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to your daily ePaper and premium newsletters.

Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Dayton Daily News. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.

X