“The most memorable I think for me when I tell the story is that when we talk about throwing out the records, anything can happen in this game, what happened to J.T.,” he said Tuesday.
“What happened to J.T.” is one of the stranger moments in a rivalry full of them, and it happened to coincide with Day’s first Ohio State-Michigan game.
Two years ago, he was the quarterbacks coach, and J.T. Barrett was the Buckeyes’ record-setting senior quarterback.
Going for his fourth straight win over the Wolverines, Barrett was injured in a collision on the sideline prior to the 2017 game at Michigan Stadium, and Day found himself having to adjust on the fly.
“We're preparing, getting ready to play in that game. Right as the ball is about to kick off, J.T. is hurt, he can't go back in the game. The game hasn't even started yet. Here we go, we're in the rivalry game,” Day recalled.
Barrett ended up starting the game, but his knee injury worsened and he had to be replaced by Dwayne Haskins Jr., a redshirt freshman who had not exactly filled his coaches with confidence in his previous appearance.
“The week before we played Illinois at home in the pouring rain,” Day recalled. “Dwayne came into the game and fumbled on like his second snap. They returned it for a touchdown. We had to put J.T. and the starters back in the game, which was a complete nightmare.”
>>RELATED: 7 things to know about Ohio State-Michigan | What is Justin Fields’ status?
Although Haskins later returned to throw a touchdown pass to Binjimen Victor in Ohio State’s 52-14 win, the lack of ball security is what stuck in his coach’s mind.
“That's my last memory of how Dwayne was doing on the field,” Day said. “Now we are in the rivalry game, trying to win the game.
“I think his first two snaps were two false starts. It was third-and-3, a false start. It was third-and-8, we got a false start. Third-and-13, threw the fade to Austin Mack. From there, he stepped into it.”
The Buckeyes rallied from a 20-14 deficit to win 31-20.
>>RELATED: Ohio State wins ‘street fight’ with Michigan
A legend was born in Haskins, and the seeds of understanding just what Ohio State-Michigan is all about germinated in the mind of Day, who replaced Meyer as the head coach of the Buckeyes in January.