“We’re still within the standards of OHSAA,” Taylor said. “Our students were expected to have a higher grade-point average than other schools, so that sets us up to lose students.”
Other school districts have a variety of policies on the issue. Fairmont and Centerville high schools require academic intervention for student-athletes with GPAs between 1.5 and 1.99, with those at 1.49 and below ineligible. Fairborn High School requires a flat 2.0 minimum GPA to be eligible. Troy and Stebbins require only the OHSAA minimum of passing five one-credit courses, with no GPA floor.
RELATED: Dunbar boys win 10th state track championship
Joe Lacey was the only school board member to vote against the change, saying it doesn’t take too much effort to get a “C” average, and the district should incentivize students to do so. He added that Dayton Public Schools has won numerous state championships with the existing 2.0 policy, and that the change would look bad after last year’s very public eligibility problems on the Dunbar football team.
“We just had a very big problem with academic eligibility and this, it looks like, is our response … that we’re going to lower the bar, and I think that sends the wrong message to our students,” Lacey said.
Superintendent Rhonda Corr said students in the intervention program could “get that relationship with a coach or teacher or someone who’s important to them, and have the study table policy … I think it might take a child who was ready to (drop out), and this could be the catalyst that keeps them there.”
RELATED: Dayton school board re-hires embattled athletic director
Taylor agreed, saying, “There’s proof that students who participate in extracurricular activities within the schools perform better … Then, the people they are hanging out with are their teammates as opposed to maybe someone out on the streets who doesn’t have the same goals.”
To remain eligible, those student-athletes whose GPA is between 1.0 and 1.99 must be taking at least five one-credit classes, and must remain enrolled in the academic intervention “for at least one calendar year, must attend all study tables, and must make satisfactory progress toward the established goal of a 2.0 GPA each academic quarter.”
There was initial confusion on the definition of progress toward a 2.0 GPA. DPS Athletic Director Mark Baker clarified Wednesday that the starting point would be the student-athlete’s GPA for the most recent academic quarter. In order to stay eligible, the student’s GPA would have to be higher in the next quarter.
RELATED: DPS rehires Powell as Dunbar football coach
For example, a student with a 1.42 GPA in last spring’s fourth quarter can play football starting now if he is active in the intervention program, but if his first-quarter GPA in October is 1.42 or lower, he would lose eligibility at the start of the second quarter.
Baker said DPS is still in the process of figuring out how many students will be affected by the new policy, but said, “We believe it’s going to be a small percentage.” He said “an overwhelming number” of teachers have expressed interest in helping students in the intervention program. The mandatory study tables are one hour Monday through Thursday.
“We’re going to look at a number of different ways to assist them — certainly with our teachers but also with some peer tutoring,” Baker said. “The coaches have an expectation to be at the study tables to assist them as well.”
RELATED: Football recruits headed for top college teams
The fall sports tryout window has passed, but Baker said if newly eligible students ask to play a fall sport — football, volleyball, soccer, cross country, golf or girls tennis — coaches will allow them to do so if they meet the intervention requirements. The policy applies to students in grades 7-12 for all extracurricular activities.
“We’re not just saying that it’s OK for a student-athlete to make the grade,” school board President Robert Walker said. “We want the district to be more proactive, where if there’s an athlete who isn’t able to make the grade, there will be those supports surrounding him or her and challenge them to be the best that they can be.”
Adil Baguirov abstained from the vote after first trying to find a middle ground. Ron Lee was absent. Taylor, Walker, Hazel Rountree and John McManus voted yes.