Key is a four-star prospect, according to 247Sports.com. He ranks 115th in the 2020 class. He also has scholarship offers from Penn State, Duquesne, Tulane, George Washington, Florida, Cincinnati, St. Bonaventure and others.
Key attended Brentwood High School (N.Y.) on Long Island for his first two years before transferring to Long Island Lutheran this year. He averaged 15.9 points per game as a sophomore, according to Newsday.com.