High School baseball: D-III No. 1 Butler tops No. 4 Tippecanoe 11-5 in battle of unbeatens

Butler High School senior Mason Reckner tags out Tippecanoe's James Merry on Wednesday at Upper Valley Medical Center Sports Complex in Tipp City. Butler won 11-5. Michael Cooper / STAFF PHOTO

Butler High School senior Mason Reckner tags out Tippecanoe's James Merry on Wednesday at Upper Valley Medical Center Sports Complex in Tipp City. Butler won 11-5. Michael Cooper / STAFF PHOTO

The Division III top-ranked Butler High School baseball team beat one of its biggest rivals in a battle of unbeaten teams.

The Aviators defeated D-III No. 4 Tippecanoe 11-5 in a Miami Valley League Miami Division game on Wednesday evening at Upper Valley Medical Center Sports Complex in Tipp City.

Butler sophomore catcher Jackson Schilling went 4-4 with three doubles and five RBIs and junior Paxton Dwenger and sophomore Koby Dues each had three hits as the Aviators improved to 18-0 and 13-0 in the MVL Miami Division.

Tippecanoe senior Preston Zumwalt and sophomore James Merry each had three hits for the Red Devils (18-1).

Butler senior Hunter Richardson threw 5⅔ innings for the Aviators, allowing two runs on six hits with seven strikeouts. He also went 2-for-4 with two doubles.

The Aviators never trailed in the game. They took an early lead 1-0 lead in the first inning on an RBI double by Schilling. Butler extended its lead to 5-0 in the fourth after RBI singles from Dwenger and senior Mason Reckner and a two-RBI single by sophomore Tate Richardson.

Tippecanoe cut the lead to 5-2 on a two-RBI single by Merry, but the Red Devils wouldn’t get any closer. The Aviators added two runs in the sixth and four in the seventh to increase their lead to 11-2.

Tippecanoe High School junior Cayden McKinney delivers a pitch to the plate during their game against Butler on Wednesday, May 7 at Upper Valley Sports Complex in Tipp City. Butler won 11-5. Michael Cooper / STAFF PHOTO

icon to expand image

The Red Devils added three in the bottom of the seventh.

Round 2 is coming later this week. The Red Devils travel to Butler at 7 p.m. Friday.

Key moment: Trailing 1-0 with two outs in the bottom of the fourth, the Red Devils loaded the bases for Zumwalt. The senior smoked a line drive to third base, but it was caught by Dues to end the threat. The Aviators would respond with four runs in the top of the fifth inning.

Key stat: The Aviators collected 16 hits in the game, including five doubles.

About the Author