No winner: Wild Bengals-Panthers game ends in tie

It was tied for the longest game in Cincinnati Bengals history and was highlighted by some of the longest plays in team annals, but it ended only with a lot of long faces as Mike Nugent missed a 36-yarder at the gun in overtime for a 37-37 tie against the Carolina Panthers.

Giovani Bernard had an 89-yard touchdown run in the first half, and Adam Jones returned a kickoff 97 yards late in the fourth quarter to set up Jeremy Hill’s game-tying 3-yard touchdown run.

Both team’s kicked field goals on their first possessions of overtime to extend the game before Nugent missed on the final play to send the Bengals to 3-1-1. The Panthers moved to 3-2-1.

Bernard’s touchdown was the second-longest run in Bengals history behind a 96-yarder by Corey Dillon in 2001. And Jones’ kick return came after the Panthers had taken a 31-24 lead on a 13-yard touchdown pass from Carolina quarterback Cam Newton to tight end Greg Olsen with 4:50 left in the game.

It was the longest kick return in franchise history that did not result in a touchdown and was tied for the fifth-longest overall.

The return led to Hill’s TD run that tied the game at 31-31, and three plays later Reggie Nelson picked off Newton to set up a Nugent 38-yard field goal that put the Bengals up 34-31 with 2:11 to go.

But Newton drove the Panthers 54 yards in 12 plays and Graham Gano hit a 44-yarder as time expired to force OT.

The Bengals won the overtime coin toss, took the ball and drove 56 yards in 13 plays to set up a Nugent 42-yarder. Carolina answered with a 12-play, 55-yard drive that Gano capped with a 36-yard field goal that tied the game 37-37 with 2:11 to go.

Andy Dalton hit James Wright with a 24-yard pass and a roughing-the-passer call put the Bengals in position for the game-winner, but Nugent was wide right.

About the Author