- Thomas Bailey: Assistant Superintendent and Chief Operating Officer, Three Rivers Local Schools; Former Head Principal (Grades K-12), Three River Local Schools
- Kirk Koennecki: Principal, Marion Harding High School, Marion City Schools; Former Principal, Springfield High School
- Eugene Lolli: Principal, Fairborn High School; Former Superintendent, Springboro Community Schools
- Carl Metzger: Assistant Superintendent, South-Western City Schools; Former Superintendent, Marion Local Schools
- Mark North: Superintendent, Lebanon City Schools; Former Assistant Superintendent, Groveport Madison Local Schools
- Tyrone Olverson: Superintendent, Finneytown Local Schools; Former Director of Curriculum & Instruction, Licking Heights Local Schools
- Jeff Patrick: Superintendent, Franklin Monroe Local Schools, Pitsburg, Ohio; Former Superintendent, Bradford Exempted Village Schools
- Jennifer Pennczarski: Superintendent, Kenton City Schools; Former Principal, Tri-Valley Middle School, Dresden, Ohio
- Dr. Brad Ritchey: Director of Instructional Programs, Parma City Schools; Former Principal, Parma Normandy High School
Terry Riley was appointed Fairborn interim superintendent in September after Dave Scarberry stepped aside due to health reasons.
The district’s goal is to hire a superintendent by March 17, with the new leader starting in June or July.