McCollister, of Union Twp., starred in the 2015 show “Neighbors with Benefits” along with his then-wife, Diana, about couples embracing a swinger lifestyle in Hamilton Twp. Viewer backlash led A&E to cancel the show after only airing two episodes.
Credit: Warren County Jail
Credit: Warren County Jail
Erica Lynne Grove, 43, of Union Twp. was indicted on 24 charges: four counts of rape, one count of corrupting another with drugs, eight counts of illegal use of minor or impaired person in nudity-oriented material or performance, two counts of endangering children and and four counts of sexual conduct with an animal.
Credit: Warren County Jail
Credit: Warren County Jail
An investigation began after Google in June 2025 submitted a tip to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children of possible child sexual abuse material. The tip was then forwarded to the Ohio Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force and the Warren County Sheriff’s Office for investigation, according to a release from Warren County Prosecutor David Fornshell.
Sheriff’s detectives determined the alleged child sexual abuse material was associated with an account belonging to McCollister, the release stated.
“As part of this review, in addition to the (child sexual abuse material), investigators located video files of McCollister and Grove engaged in various types of sexual conduct with two dogs,” the prosecutor’s office stated.
In addition, an investigation “uncovered evidence that Grove and McCollister drugged a female child who was under the age of 6 for the specific purpose of raping and engaging in various other types of sexual assault of the child. Detectives also discovered additional (child sexual abuse material) involving the child,” according to the release.
“Just when we thought that sex with the dogs was going to be the most horrific part of this case, the detectives discovered evidence of the drugging and raping of a little girl,” Fornshell said. “It’s really difficult to even process.”
Grove and McCollister are scheduled to be arraigned Wednesday in Warren County Common Pleas Court.
About the Author
